Walton Farm Cows
The 30,000 most productive New Zealand farms and the agricultural businesses that support them generate around $17 billion in export earnings a year – around 48% of the country's total exports. Because of the importance of industry, even small improvements in agricultural productivity have a huge effect on earnings. A 3% productivity increase would equate to $500 million in export revenue for New Zealand. But with New Zealand farmers already some of the most efficient, where will these productivity gains come from? Technology will definitely be a key.
Technological innovation has always played a critical role in the success of New Zealand's agriculture industry. Early innovations included the development of refrigerated shipping, the introduction of mechanical milking machines in the 1890s, and, more recently, the invention of the electric fence and the rotary milking platform.
While New Zealand scientists and companies continue to develop new farm technologies and refine existing ones, a new approach is being developed. Rather than have technologies working separately, they are being wired together into integrated systems, which allows the technologies to interact and, in some cases, work synergistically – greatly increasing the efficiency of farming operations.
Innovation
Drafting cows with Protrack and RFID (click to enlarge)
Milk cooling with Polar Wrap on the vat (click to enlarge)
The approach is being demonstrated on the Waikato dairy farm of David and Raewyn Bennett. Preliminary results indicate the approach can dramatically and sustainably lift farm output and profitability by boosting production and lowering costs.
Output from the farm is well above the industry average of 824kg ms/ha, and currently exceeds 2,900kg ms/ha. Effective farm surplus is forecast to exceed $3,900/ha this year compared to the industry weighted average of $1,900/ha. Fertiliser application has been reduced by over 60% and discharges to surrounding watersheds are well within Waikato Regional Council environmental limits.
While much of the higher output and reduced environmental impacts of the operation must be credited to David and Raewyn's farming system and expertise, it's clear that technology is a key enabler.
The Walton Farm Integrated Farm Management project was initiated and is managed by Innovation Waikato with the support and facilitation of New Zealand Trade and Enterprise. The project involves four main technology partners: Livestock Improvement, Gallagher Group, Agricom, and Telecom, as well as other technology companies and research organisations. The technologies being trialled include advanced systems for effluent treatment, animal identification, milk sensing and measurement, animal performance measurement, herd performance measurement, energy conservation, data collection and analysis, system monitoring and communications.
Background
Over the past decade or so, competition from other agriculture producers (often subsidised ones) has heated up considerably. This is particularly true in commodity markets, such as milk powder and frozen beef. New Zealand farmers have had to intensify operations to remain competitive. The dairy sector has intensified by increasing the number of stock units per hectare and boosting milk production. The number of dairy cows in the country increased 34% between 1994 and 2002; while the amount of land used for dairying increased 12%.
When David and Raewyn Bennett began farming their property 12 years ago, they milked 300 cows; this season they milked up to 940. Effective management of a herd this size depends on being able to identify individual animals and monitor a range of herd and individual cow variables. But gathering data and manually recording it can be a tedious and labour intensive chore, and, furthermore, data is only valuable if it can be turned into information. In management terms, information is most valuable when it can be accessed and applied in real time.
Functionality
Weighing cows with the Dairy Scale (click to enlarge)
DTS cellular vat monitor (click to enlarge)
At the Walton Farm a number of data gathering and recording technologies have been integrated to automatically identify animals, collect data, and process it into instantly accessible information. Each cow bears an ear tag containing a RFID (radio frequency identification) chip, which allows animals to be identified automatically by chip readers. Information gathered about an animal can be labelled with the animal's code and stored in a central computer.
Liveweight is a key piece of information needed to effectively manage livestock.
Agritech company Gallagher have installed its automatic DairyScale system on the farm. Positioned at the exit of the milking shed, the scales seamlessly integrate animal weighing into the milking process. Weighing cows helps monitor animal health and production. Potentially, by calculating average herd weight, the system would allow the Bennetts to adjust feed regimes to match grass growth with nutritional demand.
In the near future, electronic meters will record milk production from individual cows - an essential component of any breeding/genetic improvement program. At present, daily milk production from the herd is calculated and posted on the FencePost website.
These high tech improvements are helpful by themselves but if they are integrated they work synergistically, creating even greater efficiencies. By integrating the DairyScale system with Protrack animal identification and management package, animal weight can be used to monitor animal health. Animals that have lost significant weight over a designated period can be readily identified and drafted-off automatically. Identifying sick animals this way, allows for timely treatment and a speedy return to full production. Correlating individual animal weights with their milk production allows farmers to select cows that produce the most milk for their weight, and cull less productive cattle.
Improvements
Wireless broadband at the Dairy
(click to enlarge)
Solar powered wireless repeater
(click to enlarge)
Because each animal is identified by a radio tag, some herd management processes can be automated. Animal records, housed in the Protrack software package, developed by the Livestock Improvement Corporation, can be checked prior to milking. Protrack can issue alerts for cows which need to be identified for any range of animal health or management needs-as programmed by the farmer. The software may be linked to a system of automated drafting gates, which, depending how they are programmed, can automatically separate animals from the rest of the herd.
On one occasion Protrack set off an audio alarm to warn David and Raewyn Bennett that a cow being treated with antibiotics had slipped unnoticed into the milking herd. If the technology hadn't alerted them to the interloper, it could have contaminated the 30,000 litre vat of milk and potentially the entire tanker load.
The key to integrating the different monitoring and management systems is communication. The farmhouse and cowshed at Walton Farm are connected to the Internet with Xtra wireless broadband, while an 802.11 Wi-fi network supplied by the Rural Link extends coverage across the farm. Broadband Internet access provides the farmers and their staff with access to databases held by Fonterra and Livestock Improvement. Similarly, Fonterra uses a remote monitoring service (RMS) track milk vat temperatures and levels, which will allow the company to better coordinate milk pick-ups. David and Raewyn can access the same milk vat data, even while they are away from the farm.
Environment
New pasture species with AR37 endophyte (click to enlarge)
Feeding maize silage and supplements (click to enlarge)
While intensification has lifted production in the dairy sector – milk solid production per hectare rose 34% between 1994 and 2002 – it is clear that this increase has come at some environmental cost. The use of nitrogen-based fertiliser to boost grass growth has increased dramatically: between 1996 and 2002, the use of nitrogenous urea fertiliser alone jumped 160%.
If applied excessively, nitrogen leaks into the wider environment. Nitrogen is highly mobile and easily enters streams and groundwater reservoirs, leading to the deterioration of groundwater quality and the eutrophication of fresh and coastal waters. It is a particularly insidious problem as there is a lag between the application of nutrients and their appearance in waterways.
The deterioration of Lake Taupo's water quality today is due to nitrogen applied to adjoining farmland up to 50 years ago. The other major contaminant produced by intensive dairying is faecal matter: a single cow produces as much sewage as 14 humans.
On the demonstration farm, effluent is piped to a storage pond and then sprayed over paddocks as a manure slurry, using a system of pumps, rain guns and a travelling irrigator. The farm has a part-time worker dedicated to effluent disposal. Investment in effluent disposal pays for itself through savings in fertiliser costs. But because not all of the herd's feed is grown on the farm, the Bennetts have to take great care not to apply more nutrients to the land than are taken from it. This is particularly important given the area's high rainfall and the farm's high water table.
Fertiliser is only applied where necessary. On Walton Farm, Overseer nutrient budget software developed by AgResearch provides a mathematical model that helps the Bennetts and their fertiliser consultant from Ravensdown Fertiliser Cooperative work out exactly what quantity of nutrients are needed on each part of the farm. David and Raewyn use precision farm mapping software, Resolution, to plan the application of fertiliser, as well as activities like maize and regrassing.
Comparisons
Milking at the Walton farm
(click to enlarge)
Hot water heat recovery with Mahana Blue (click to enlarge)
Northern Hemisphere dairying is largely based on the high input/high output "cut and carry" model. Feed is brought to the animals and their wastes are removed for disposal. While production per cow is often impressively high, it is achieved at very high cost – expensive machinery is required and it is labour and energy intensive. In New Zealand, dairying is based for the most part on a low input/high profit grass-based model. While a pure grass-based system can't match the high production per cow levels of the cut-and-carry agriculture, profitability is achieved through having lower input costs.
The system may be low input but it is definitely not low tech. It still costs money to grow grass and, as with any business, the successful farmer is the one that can manage different combinations of inputs to produce the best profit. Grass-roots technology helps improve the ratio of revenue to costs.
The basis of the New Zealand system is the pasture plants themselves. The development of specialised cultivars of perennial ryegrass, and superior, more nutritious strains of white clover, were breakthroughs which significantly boosted agricultural productivity in New Zealand. (So too was the development of a seed certification system, which provides a quality guarantee for seed buyers.) Subsequently, many specialised pasture cultivars have been developed for specific farming needs. Cultivars of ryegrass, for example, have been developed to cope with drought, hard grazing, and the treading of stock. Clovers and other forage legumes have been specifically bred for low fertility areas, acid soils, and pest and disease resistance.
A new ryegrass cultivar is being trialled on the demonstration farm. Developed by seed company Agricom, the cultivar contains a strain of endophytic fungus – AR37. Ryegrass inoculated with the fungi appears to develop deeper and stronger roots, which help the plant persist for longer in pasture. The presence of the fungus – developed by AgResearch – not only boosts grass production, but also offers natural protection against pasture pests such as root aphids and porina caterpillars as well as Argentine stem weevils, reducing the need for pesticide applications. At the same time AR37 does not release the alkaloids made by wild endophytes, which cause reduced production and sickness (ryegrass staggers) in animals.
Requirements
The link between pasture performance and returns is a simple one: if farmers can grow more grass they can put more milk in the vat and send more milk solids through the gate. The adoption of the AR37 ryegrass variety on Walton Farm is estimated to result in between 9% and 20% increased milk production off that part of the farm. AgResearch figures indicate the gains from AR37 could translate to between $450/hectare and $800/hectare each year – if the longer period between the need to regrass pasture is factored in.
Dairy farms have around-the-clock energy demands, with the milking shed being the main consumer of electricity. Electricity is used to drive the vacuum and milk pumps during milking, to cool milk and to produce the hot water used to clean equipment. When David and Raewyn Bennett replaced the farm's 32-aside herringbone dairy shed with a 54 bail rotary shed, a number of systems were used to reduce electricity use. They ensured that hot water cylinders were insulated, and that both these and vacuum pumps were matched with their respective demands. Variable speed drives are utilised on pumps to reduce power consumption. The project team installed additional an additional insulating cover on the milk vat (the Polar Wrap from Dairy Technology Services), as well as a Danfoss Mahana Blue unit. The Mahana Blue recovers heat generated while chilling milk, and uses it to heat the hot water to 80 degrees, effectively removing the hot water component of the energy bill.
Energy
A 2002 study by Massey University researcher found the average overall energy use per hectare by New Zealand dairy farmers was lower than anywhere reported overseas.
New Zealand's energy consumption in dairy production is measured against overseas producers by its overall energy ratio. This ratio (OER) is the all-important ratio of the total primary energy input per kilogram of milk-solids to the calorific energy output in those milk-solids. New Zealand's OER is 0.59 compared to an estimated 2.8 in the USA and a range of 0.67 to 2.4 in European countries.
Some individual farms, however, particularly those with pumped irrigation or high nitrogen application rates, may have higher OERs than those calculated for some conventional and organic dairy farms in Europe.
The energy use on New Zealand dairy farms is calculated to be about 18 gigajoules (GJ) annually per effective milking hectare. The most significant contributions to that total energy use on the 'national average' dairy farm are fertiliser (35%), electricity (25%) and fossil fuels (20%). Estimates of the energy used in running capital equipment and farm structures add a further 13% to the total energy use. On spray irrigated farms, electricity use jumped to become the most significant energy input at 40%.
Results
Protrack herd management system (click to enlarge)
Cows pass through the drafting system (click to enlarge)
The Walton farm demonstrates the commercial and environmental advantages of integrating technologies. While the approach appears best suited to large farms looking to fine-tune operations and further increase production, profit and sustainability, it's clear the approach will can be applied with useful effects for smaller operations as well; Farmers could select a subset of the available technologies to suit their farming systems and goals. It's likely as the advantages of the approach become obvious, manufacturers will work together and make it easier for consumers to integrate separate technologies and form on-farm systems.
The integrated approach demonstrated by the Walton model farm is likely to be applied to include beef, sheep and deer farms. These will require different mixes of technologies, but the underlying design philosophy remains the same – getting technologies to work together, rather than in isolation, to create a powerful management tool. Innovation Waikato has won a tender let by the government agency to develop a business case for what would be New Zealand's second ICT show farm to demonstrate the benefits of investing in technology.
The New Zealand dairy industry began in 1814, with the importation of two cows and a bull. For decades, New Zealand enjoyed natural competitive advantages over other dairy exporting nations. Our benign climate and lush pastures and technological savvy allowed us to overcome the disadvantage of our distance from major markets. But in recent years, the competition has caught up. We are no longer the world's lowest cost producer of milk. Argentina and Chile have this distinction. New competitors are rapidly evolving: Brazil recently became self-sufficient in milk production, and India and China are building their production capacity. Technological innovation is more important than ever. The Walton model farm is but one approach to keeping the New Zealand dairy industry ahead of the pack.